Climate change and agriculture: a warning with opportunities

On May 27, the National Academy of Engineering of Uruguay (ANIU) inaugurated its series of talks on climate change with a virtual conference given by Dr. Walter E. Baethgen. Dr. Walter E. Baethgena senior researcher at the Columbia Climate School and acting director of the International Research Institute for Climate and Society (IRI) in New York.

The event also featured remarks by Dr. Rafael Terraclimatologist and professor at the University of the Republic.

Presentation by Walter E. Baethgen, Ph.D.

Presentation by Dr. Rafael Terra

 

Change is real… and faster than ever before.

Baethgen was adamant from the start: “The climate has always changed, yes, but never at this speed.

It showed how global temperatures and CO₂ levels have reached values unheard of in the last 800,000 years… and they did so in barely a century.

This speed, he explained, is the main evidence that this is not a natural cycle, but a phenomenon driven by human activity.

The core of the problem: fossil fuels

Much of his presentation focused on dismantling false equivalencies.

Despite the public debate often focused on livestock, Baethgen stressed that the main source of global emissions is fossil fuels, which account for about 75% of the total.

climate-change-the-fossil-fuels-problem

“Methane leaks from coal mines, oil wells and natural gas wells emit more than all the world’s livestock,” he explained, adding:

“It’s good to improve what we do in agriculture, but let’s not lose sight of where the real problem is.”

Uncertainty and bad science

Another substantial part of the conference was devoted to criticizing the irresponsible use of climate models.

Baethgen questioned those who make detailed projections of climate or 80-year agricultural yields without clarifying the margins of error.

“That’s not only scientifically incorrect; it’s also dangerous, because decisions are made with misleading information,” he warned.

Instead, he proposed a more realistic approach: use the models as general guidelines, and work with the climate data available today to design adaptation strategies.

Extreme events: the most concrete threat

According to Baethgen, climate change is already present in Uruguay, and not so much in the form of linear trends, but as a greater frequency of extreme events.

He cited as an example the increased variability in summer rainfall, which today can go from historical deficits to excesses in a very short time.

Extreme events: the most concrete threat

“The biggest threat from climate change is the intensification of extremes, not the average,” he said.

And he proposed prioritizing adaptation to this new reality, rather than waiting for future certainties.

Agribusiness can be part of the solution

Despite the warnings, the message was not apocalyptic. Baethgen also spoke of opportunities.

Among them is the sequestration of carbon in soils through sustainable practices, which could better position Uruguay in international markets.

“It’s not a permanent solution, but it buys us time. And if done right, it can be a competitive advantage,” he said.

Rafael Terra’s comments

After the main presentation, Dr. Rafael Terra offered a complementary view from the academic climatology.

He agreed with Baethgen on the urgency of adapting to the current climate and on the rigorous use of models.

He also stressed the importance of working with time and space scales appropriateto real decision making.

Rafael Terra's comments

Terra also remarked that, although there is uncertainty, it is not an excuse for inaction: “Not knowing everything does not mean not knowing anything. We must use what we know to act prudently, but also firmly”.

Exchange with the public

The conference closed with a series of questions from the audience, moderated by Mario Allegri.

Topics discussed included:

  • The lack of specific public policies for climate adaptation.
  • The role of multiple indicators in defining sustainability.
  • And the challenges of communicating scientific information without falling into misleading simplifications.

Baethgen was clear in his final answer: “Science has to be at the service of society. And for that, we have to communicate better, but without losing depth”.